Debriefing

A post-award meeting where the government explains why your proposal was not selected.

Full Definition

A debriefing is a formal post-award meeting or written communication where the contracting officer explains the basis for the source selection decision to an unsuccessful offeror. Under FAR 15.506, for negotiated procurements (FAR Part 15), offerors have the right to request a debriefing within 3 calendar days of receiving notification of contract award or exclusion from the competitive range. The government must provide the overall evaluated rating of both your proposal and the awardee's proposal, the rationale for the award decision, a summary of significant weaknesses and deficiencies identified in your proposal, and answers to reasonable questions about the evaluation. Notably, debriefings must not reveal proprietary information, trade secrets, or point-by-point comparisons with other offerors. For sealed bidding (FAR Part 14), debriefing rights are more limited. The debriefing can be conducted in person, by telephone, or in writing, at the government's discretion.

Why It Matters

Debriefings are invaluable learning opportunities that reveal how evaluators perceived your proposal, what specific weaknesses they identified, and how your approach compared to the winning offer. Always request a debriefing when you lose a competitive procurement — even if you believe the evaluation was fair. Prepare specific questions in advance covering each evaluation factor. Take detailed notes during the debriefing and share findings with your entire proposal team for lessons learned. Common feedback areas include lack of specific staffing qualifications, vague technical approaches, insufficient past performance relevance, and unrealistic pricing. Use debriefing feedback to create a corrective action plan for future proposals. Debriefings also provide the factual foundation needed to determine whether a GAO protest is warranted — you must request a debriefing before filing a protest to preserve your protest timeline under the 2018 NDAA enhanced debriefing provisions.

Example

After losing a $12 million competitive IT services procurement, a contractor requests a post-award debriefing within the 3-day window. During the meeting, the contracting officer reveals that their technical approach received a "Good" rating while the winner received "Excellent" — primarily because the winner proposed named key personnel with specific agency experience and provided a more detailed transition plan. The contractor documents these findings, updates their proposal playbook, and on the next similar opportunity recruits key personnel with the required agency experience. They win the follow-on procurement six months later.

Related Guide

Learn more about Debriefing →